Butler Beach offers a laid-back Atlantic coastline lifestyle on Anastasia Island just south of historic St. Augustine. Buyers exploring Butler Beach homes for sale will find uncrowded shoreline, local character, and quick access to A1A, the Intracoastal Waterway, and area parks—plus nearby shopping and dining.

Real estate options in Butler Beach include oceanfront houses, beachside cottages, and low-maintenance condos with boardwalk access. Whether you’re a seasonal owner, retiree, or full-time coastal resident, this St. Johns County enclave blends natural beauty with everyday convenience.

Butler Beach Lifestyle & Highlights

• Walkable public beach access and scenic dune walkovers
• Mix of single-family homes and oceanfront condo communities
• Minutes to the Intracoastal Waterway, boat ramps, and Matanzas Inlet
• Quiet streets, local eateries, and no high-rise skyline
• Easy access to A1A and Historic St. Augustine

Details About Butler Beach

• Property Types: Single-family homes, townhomes, and oceanfront condos
• Location: Butler Beach, Anastasia Island (St. Johns County, FL)
• Zip Code: 32080
• Pricing: Varies by proximity to ocean/ICW and property type
• HOA: Many non-HOA streets; condo communities have moderate dues

• Nearby: County beach parks, local shops, and dining along A1A
• Beach Access: Multiple public walkovers and vehicle beach ramps nearby
• Commute: ~15–20 minutes to Historic Downtown St. Augustine
• Lifestyle: Relaxed coastal living with strong rental and second-home appeal

Anastasia Island Communities, Developments, Subdivisions & Condos

Explore more communities within Anastasia Island—one of St. Johns County’s most desirable coastal regions for beach living, waterfront homes, and island-style neighborhoods.