Anastasia Island blends stunning Atlantic beaches with vibrant community charm just across the bridge from Historic Downtown St. Augustine. Buyers exploring Anastasia Island homes for sale are drawn to the barrier island’s wide beaches, family-friendly parks, walkable beach towns, and a range of home types from oceanfront condos to classic Florida bungalows.

Real estate in Anastasia Island offers something for everyone—vacation homes, short-term rental potential, gated communities, and long-term residences. From Butler Beach and Crescent Beach down to St. Augustine Beach, buyers enjoy a relaxed lifestyle close to both the Atlantic Ocean and the Matanzas River.

Why Buy on Anastasia Island

• Access to wide, walkable beaches and natural parks
• Highly desirable St. Augustine Beach community vibe
• Mix of single-family homes, gated subdivisions, and oceanfront condos
• Close to top-rated schools, restaurants, and beachfront attractions
• Convenient to downtown via the Bridge of Lions

Details About Anastasia Island

• Property Types: Single-family homes, condos, townhomes, beachfront bungalows
• Location: Barrier island stretching from the Matanzas Inlet to the Bridge of Lions
• Zip Codes: 32080, 32084
• Price Range: ~$350,000 to $3.5M+ depending on proximity to water and community
• HOA: Range from non-HOA streets to gated communities with resort-style amenities

• Nearby: Anastasia State Park, St. Augustine Amphitheatre, shopping, restaurants
• Commute: ~5–15 minutes to downtown via A1A or 312 Bridge
• Lifestyle: Laid-back beach life with easy access to historic sites and nature

Anastasia Island Communities, Developments, Subdivisions & Condos

Explore more communities within Anastasia Island—one of St. Johns County’s most desirable coastal regions for beach living, waterfront homes, and island-style neighborhoods.